COSTELLO'S NEIGHBORHOOD PIZZA SRQ.

Florida DBPR

6574 SUPERIOR AVE · SARASOTA, FLORIDA

Passed most recent inspection (Dec 2025), 1 high-priority violation noted.

3 inspections on record since 2024 · Last inspected Dec 2025 · 3 high-priority violations in the last 12 months.

THE NUMBERS

INSPECTIONS
3
VIOLATIONS
22
total on record
LAST INSPECTED
DEC 2025

INSPECTION HISTORY

DEC 18
2025
PASS 6 violations 1 HIGH PRIORITY
High Priority Chemical Safety
Original container — properly labeled, date marking, consumer advisory

Cited 1 time on this inspection

Basic Sanitation
Food contact surfaces designed, constructed, maintained, installed, located

Cited 2 times on this inspection

Basic Sanitation
Non-food contact surfaces clean

Cited 1 time on this inspection

Intermediate Plumbing & Waste
Toilet and hand-washing facilities, number, convenient, designed, installed

Cited 1 time on this inspection

Basic Other
Exiting system — adequate, good repair (reporting only)

Cited 1 time on this inspection

Intermediate Documentation & Training
Current license properly displayed

Cited 1 time on this inspection

JUL 31
2025
FAIL 7 violations 2 HIGH PRIORITY
High Priority Food Temperature
Food out of temperature

Cited 2 times on this inspection

High Priority Food Storage & Handling
Food protection, cross-contamination

Cited 1 time on this inspection

Basic Sanitation
Food contact surfaces of equipment and utensils clean

Cited 1 time on this inspection

Basic Sanitation
Storage/handling of clean equipment, utensils

Cited 1 time on this inspection

Basic Other
Single service items properly stored, handled, dispensed

Cited 1 time on this inspection

Intermediate Plumbing & Waste
Toilet and hand-washing facilities, number, convenient, designed, installed

Cited 1 time on this inspection

Basic Other
Exiting system — adequate, good repair (reporting only)

Cited 1 time on this inspection

NOV 1
2024
PASS 9 violations 2 HIGH PRIORITY
Intermediate Food Temperature
Facilities to maintain product temperature

Cited 1 time on this inspection

Intermediate Other
Potentially hazardous food properly thawed

Cited 1 time on this inspection

High Priority Other
Foods handled with minimum contact

Cited 1 time on this inspection

Basic Sanitation
Non-food contact surfaces designed, constructed, maintained, installed, located

Cited 1 time on this inspection

Basic Sanitation
Non-food contact surfaces clean

Cited 1 time on this inspection

Basic Sanitation
Storage/handling of clean equipment, utensils

Cited 1 time on this inspection

High Priority Sanitation
Restrooms with self-closing doors, fixtures operate properly, facility clean, supplied with hand-soap, disposable towels or hand drying devices, tissue, covered waste receptacles

Cited 1 time on this inspection

Basic Food Storage & Handling
Complete separation from living/sleeping area, laundry

Cited 1 time on this inspection

Basic Other
Electrical wiring — adequate, good repair (reporting only)

Cited 1 time on this inspection

Public inspection records from Florida Department of Business and Professional Regulation. Records current as of 2026-05-08. EatOrBeat reports records and does not rate restaurants. Source dataset →

Report an error on this page →

NEARBY IN SARASOTA

HEALTHY TO GO
Pass Oct 2023
NIKKI'S GREEK CAFE
Pass Dec 2025
CHICAGO BEEF COMPANY
Pass Dec 2025
YOUR CULINARY PLACE
Pass Oct 2023
SHELLS AND BONES
Pass Oct 2023
HEALTHY TO GO
Pass Dec 2022
INTERCOASTAL CHEF SERVICES LLC
Pass Mar 2022
PLAN IT EVENTS LLC
Pass Jun 2022
CATERING BY CAROL
Pass Jul 2022
EXOTIC GOURMET LLC
Pass Sep 2022
HOBSONS CHOICE BBQ
Pass Dec 2023
TAMIAMI TRAIL CATERING
Pass Oct 2023